The profile depth is the real difference
Both the Whiteside 1434 and 1478 cut a 180-degree rounded edge, but they do not cut the same shape. The 1434 is a half round (bull nose) bit that produces a full half-circle profile. The 1478 is an oval edge bit that cuts a shallower half-moon. As the catalog notes, the oval edge cut is not as prominent as the half round.
That single difference—how much of the edge is removed—drives everything else: the bit dimensions, the setup, and the projects each bit suits best.
Whiteside 1434: the full half-round profile
- 1″ Half Round Router Bit x 1/2″ Shank – Whiteside 1434: Cut radius: 1/8′′; cutting length: 1-1/2′′; large diameter: 1-15/16′′; shank: 1/2′′. These dimensions define the full half-round shape and help you confirm the bit fits your router and project scale.

1″ Half Round Router Bit x 1/2″ Shank – Whiteside 1434 - 1″ Half Round Router Bit x 1/2″ Shank – Whiteside 1434: Recommended RPM: 10,000. Use this as a starting point for setting your router speed safely.
- 1″ Half Round Router Bit x 1/2″ Shank – Whiteside 1434: A fence is required for work on a router table, and an edge guide is necessary for applications with a hand router. Plan your setup accordingly—this bit is not freehand-friendly without guidance.
Whiteside 1478: the subtler oval edge
- 1″ Oval Edge Router Bit – Whiteside 1478: Bead opening: 1′′; bead depth: 3/16′′; cutting length: 1-1/4′′; large diameter: 1′′; shank: 1/2′′. The smaller depth and diameter create a more restrained profile than the 1434.

1″ Oval Edge Router Bit – Whiteside 1478 - 1″ Oval Edge Router Bit – Whiteside 1478: Cuts a 180-degree half-moon design along the edge of the workpiece. Confirms the oval edge is still a rounded profile, just less pronounced.
- 1″ Oval Edge Router Bit – Whiteside 1478: The catalog notes the cut is not as prominent as the Half Rounds. This is the key trade-off: a gentler look that may suit different design goals.
1434 vs 1478 at a glance
- Profile style: 1434: half round (bull nose). 1478: oval edge (shallower half-moon).
- Cut radius vs bead depth: 1434 has a 1/8′′ cut radius; 1478 has a 3/16′′ bead depth. They are measured differently, so compare the overall profile rather than the numbers alone.
- Large diameter: 1434: 1-15/16′′; 1478: 1′′.
- Cutting length: 1434: 1-1/2′′; 1478: 1-1/4′′.
- Shank: Both have a 1/2′′ shank.
- Recommended RPM: 1434: 10,000 RPM. The 1478 record does not list a recommended RPM, so check your router manufacturer’s guidance.
When the half round 1434 makes sense
Choose the 1434 when you want a pronounced, classic bull nose edge that reads as a full half-circle from the side. Its larger diameter and cutting length suit thicker stock or projects where the rounded edge is a design feature, such as built-in shelving or heavy-duty shop fixtures.
- You need a full 180-degree round: The 1434 cuts a complete half-round profile, not a shallow oval.
- Your router table has a fence: The catalog requires a fence for router table use and an edge guide for hand routing.
- You can run at 10,000 RPM: Set your router to the recommended speed before cutting.
When the oval edge 1478 makes sense
Pick the 1478 when you want a softer, more restrained rounded edge. The catalog specifically mentions cutting boards and charcuterie boards as good applications—projects where a gentle half-moon profile adds comfort and style without dominating the edge.
- You want a subtle profile: The oval edge cut is less prominent than the half round, giving a quieter look.
- You are making cutting boards or serving pieces: The catalog calls out cutting boards and charcuterie boards as ideal uses.
- You prefer a smaller bit diameter: The 1478 has a 1′′ large diameter, which can be easier to control on smaller workpieces.
Setup and compatibility notes
Both bits have a 1/2′′ shank, so they fit routers with 1/2′′ collets. The 1434 record specifies a recommended RPM of 10,000; the 1478 record does not include a recommended speed, so consult your router’s manual or the bit manufacturer for guidance. Neither record includes detailed setup steps beyond the fence and edge guide requirements for the 1434, so plan your passes and test cuts according to your own shop practices.
Remember that a fence or edge guide is not optional for the 1434—it is required for safe, controlled cuts. The 1478 record does not state a fence requirement, but using a guide is always prudent for edge profiling.
What the catalog does not settle
The supplied records do not include material-specific speed or feed rates, depth-of-cut limits, or detailed safety instructions beyond the RPM for the 1434 and the guidance requirements. They also do not list the 1478’s recommended RPM. For those details, check the manufacturer’s documentation or your router’s manual. The choice between these bits ultimately comes down to how much of the edge you want to round over: the 1434 for a full bull nose, the 1478 for a gentler oval.



